A Clean, Compact Base Near Midtown Manhattan

The overall take

Wingate by Wyndham New York Midtown South/5th Ave earns a Google rating of 4.2 from 726 reviews. Public feedback points to a straightforward city hotel that performs best as a practical base for sightseeing. Guests repeatedly describe the rooms as clean, comfortable and well organised, even when they find them small.

That distinction matters in Manhattan. The hotel is not presented in the reviews as a place for lingering indoors. Its strength is convenience. One guest chose it for access to Times Square and Summit One, while another said the location made it possible to do everything on foot. The comments support a stay built around exploring New York, with a dependable room waiting at the end of the day.

Rooms and comfort

Room size is the clearest watch-out. Several reviews mention small rooms, and one specifically notes that the sink sits in the bedroom, a layout that may feel less private when two people are sharing. Still, the available comments are positive about how the space works in practice. Guests call the rooms functional, cosy and equipped with what they needed.

Cleanliness is a consistent strength. Reviewers mention clean rooms, comfortable beds and effective air conditioning. One guest also singled out the shower’s good water pressure and appealing design. Those details suggest that the hotel’s appeal lies in reliable basics rather than expansive accommodation.

Breakfast and service

The included breakfast receives a generally favourable response. Guests describe it as quick, basic and varied enough for their needs, with fruit and pastries among the options mentioned. The breakfast area is small. One reviewer says a 30-minute limit per guest helps the space work smoothly, though that arrangement may feel structured during busy periods.

Staff service is another recurring positive. Reviewers describe the desk team as kind, welcoming and helpful, with one guest noting that staff greeted them whenever they returned. A late-shift employee was also praised for helping with coffee creamer when the guest did not want to go back outside. Another reviewer appreciated early check-in connected to Wyndham membership. Those are small interactions, but they shape the stay.

Who should book it

This hotel suits travellers who prioritise Midtown access, a clean bed and an uncomplicated morning meal over generous room dimensions. It also works for guests who expect to spend most of the day sightseeing. The comments suggest that couples and other short-stay visitors can be comfortable if they are prepared for compact quarters.

The strongest case is a busy New York itinerary. Times Square and Summit One are specifically named in the reviews, and the location is repeatedly praised for walkability. Public feedback also describes guests feeling safe and well cared for. The evidence supports a practical, service-minded choice in a central area, with room size and the confined breakfast space kept firmly in view.

Plan the rest of the trip

• More hotels in United States
• What else is worth booking in New York, United States
• All United States travel reviews
• Browse every destination we cover