The St. Regis Punta Mita Resort: Beautiful, Uneven Service

What the reviews show

The St. Regis Punta Mita Resort has a Google rating of 4.7 from 779 reviews, and the public feedback is clearly mixed beneath that strong score. Several travellers describe a beautiful, spacious property with well-kept grounds, fresh-looking rooms and a long list of amenities. One group travelling for a large birthday weekend found the food, pools, rooms and service excellent. Another family staying for five days praised the resort’s setting and facilities, while noting that service could be patchy.

The result is a resort that appears capable of delivering a high-end holiday, but not with complete consistency. That distinction matters here. Positive reviews describe an experience that feels polished and generous. Critical reviews focus on breakdowns in the details.

Rooms, grounds and amenities

The property itself is the clearest strength in the available feedback. Travellers repeatedly mention attractive grounds, spacious public areas and rooms that feel updated and luxurious. One reviewer singled out the outdoor shower as an especially memorable feature. Families and groups also found plenty to do on site, with pools and other amenities supporting a stay that does not depend on constant excursions.

The resort suits travellers who value the setting and want a substantial property rather than a small, quiet inn. Its event and wedding venue listings also fit the reports of group stays, including one birthday gathering with around 40 friends.

Service is the deciding factor

Butler service appears prominently in the reviews, with sharply different outcomes. One guest described receiving excellent attention from the butlers and praised a named butler for the care provided. Another said the assigned butler was attentive for roughly the first day before the experience declined. The family review similarly describes moments of excellent service alongside noticeably inconsistent interactions.

Dining feedback follows the same pattern. A reviewer praised a 10-course dinner, while another reported a very long wait for a simple meal and repeated requests for water and cutlery. Food was also criticised as expensive relative to its quality. These comments do not establish that every meal will be slow, but they do show that restaurant service is a recurring point of concern.

Who should book

The St. Regis Punta Mita Resort is best suited to couples, families and organised groups who place a high value on attractive rooms, pools, grounds and on-property amenities. It is less suitable for travellers who expect flawless personal service at every stage of a premium stay.

Billing deserves particular attention. One reviewer reported a disputed additional charge of while another said the hotel had not responded to follow-up emails after a disappointing visit. Those are individual reports, not proof of a property-wide practice. Still, guests should review charges during the stay and keep written records of any unresolved issue.

The overall verdict is positive on the physical resort and qualified on execution. The high Google rating reflects substantial satisfaction, but the critical reviews identify real service and administration risks. A carefully managed booking could produce an excellent stay. Expectations should remain measured.

Plan the rest of the trip

• More hotels in Mexico
• What else is worth booking in Punta de Mita, Mexico
• All Mexico travel reviews
• Browse every destination we cover