The St. Regis New York: Historic Luxury With Some Wear

What reviews show

The St. Regis New York has a Google rating of 4.5 from 1,888 reviews. Public feedback presents a storied luxury hotel with real strengths, though the experience is not uniformly smooth. Guests repeatedly notice the building’s history, elegant interiors and attentive staff. One reviewer highlights the hotel’s history dating back to 1904 and says the room combined old-world character with modern comfort. Another describes the room as well appointed, but old.

That split runs through the reviews. The hotel can feel special, particularly when the service matches its reputation. It can also feel less convincing when arrival arrangements falter or the older fabric of the property becomes too apparent.

Rooms and shared spaces

The rooms receive some of the clearest praise. Reviewers describe beautiful, elegant decor and a comfortable blend of traditional style with contemporary touches. A strong shower also earns a specific mention. The atmosphere is formal and historic rather than sleek or minimalist.

The public areas draw more criticism. One guest reports little to no air conditioning in the hallways and elevators. Another says the property has “wrinkles” that come with age. The comments suggest that guests who value character will understand the appeal, while those expecting every part of a luxury hotel to feel newly refreshed may be disappointed.

Service and the bar

Staff experiences vary sharply. Several reviews describe warm, memorable hospitality, especially at the bar. Jessie is mentioned in two separate accounts for making visitors feel welcome, sharing stories from a long career at the hotel, and showing thoughtful attention to a family with children. Her suggestion about the early evening drinks helped extend one family’s visit, and she also gave the children a treat.

Another review praises an excellent bartender, Adam, at King Cole. The bar is one of the property’s strongest recurring reference points, with service and conversation adding character to a short visit.

Arrival service is less consistent. One guest says nobody greeted the party when they arrived, and assistance with luggage was not immediately available. That account stands in contrast to the highly attentive service described in the bar reviews. Expectations should be set accordingly.

Who should stay

The St. Regis New York suits travellers seeking historic atmosphere, formal design and the possibility of highly personal service. It also works for visitors who want to stop in for a drink rather than book a full stay. Families can find a welcoming experience at the bar, based on the reviews, though the overall setting is more polished than casual.

Value is the main reservation. One reviewer felt the property did not justify its cost and believed other New York options offered more. The reviews support a luxury positioning, but they also show that the building’s age and inconsistent arrival service can temper the experience. The best fit is a guest who actively values heritage and attentive staff, not someone seeking uniformly modern facilities.

Plan the rest of the trip

• More hotels in United States
• What else is worth booking in New York, United States
• All United States travel reviews
• Browse every destination we cover