The Manhattan Club: Spacious Rooms Near Central Park

Location and first impressions

The Manhattan Club sits just off Broadway in Midtown Manhattan. Central Park, Times Square and several Broadway theatres are all within an easy walk, which is why public ratings and reviews repeatedly single out the location as the property’s biggest strength. One reviewer called it the middle of everything. Another said the subway or metro is only a few minutes away, making longer trips across New York City simpler.

The lobby gives guests somewhere comfortable to wait, with leather armchairs near the entrance. That can be useful because reviews cite a 4 PM check-in time. Several travellers said they arrived early after overnight flights and asked whether they could access their rooms sooner. Early check-in is not guaranteed.

Rooms and property character

Space is the main room-related advantage. Travellers describe suites with separate bedrooms, king beds and more than 500 square feet, which is larger than many Midtown Manhattan rooms. Reviews also praise the clean rooms, comfortable beds and practical layouts. The property is a fit for guests who want room to spread out, even if a highly designed or newly renovated interior is not the priority.

This is not described as a sleek, contemporary hotel. Multiple reviews call the building a little old, and one says it was converted from a former timeshare. Those details matter when setting expectations. The draw is the amount of space and the position in Manhattan, not a polished new-build feel.

Service and on-site experience

Staff comments are consistently positive in the supplied public reviews. Guests describe the team as friendly, helpful and patient. That included a period of elevator upgrades, when the work caused some inconvenience. One family said staff remained accommodating while the upgrades were underway.

The hotel bar receives favourable individual mentions as well. Guests refer to well-made cocktails and attentive bartenders, with one specifically praising a good Old Fashioned. The available reviews do not show a wider dining program, so the bar makes more sense as a convenient evening option than as a primary reason to choose the property.

Who should stay here

The Manhattan Club suits families, couples and repeat New York City visitors looking for a central base with unusually generous rooms. It is also practical for theatre-focused trips, with several Broadway venues within walking distance. Guests may need taxis less often, while the nearby subway offers a straightforward way to reach attractions farther across the city.

The property has a Google rating of 4.3 from 2,993 reviews. Read alongside the repeated praise for location, room size and staff, that is a strong public signal. There are trade-offs: an older feel, the fixed check-in timing mentioned by guests and possible disruption during building work. For travellers who put space in Midtown Manhattan first, the balance will likely work.

Plan the rest of the trip

• More hotels in United States
• What else is worth booking in New York, United States
• All United States travel reviews
• Browse every destination we cover