Mayflower Hotel: Historic Character, Uneven Room Comfort

What the reviews show

The Mayflower Hotel draws travellers who like older San Francisco buildings and want a stay with some personality. Its public Google rating is 4.4 from 421 reviews. The strongest comments point to the historic look, central location and a generally clean arrival experience. One reviewer called the property beautiful and well maintained, noting that it was close to everything. Another enjoyed feeling right in the city, with bars and restaurants nearby.

The building itself does much of the work. Reviews refer to a charming vintage atmosphere, a striking front room with large windows and an impressive ceiling. Some rooms are described as spacious. At least one guest also found the staff accommodating. The trade-off is clear: visitors used to polished, modern accommodation may find the property dated. Here, that affects the stay rather than simply the décor.

The main concern: room conditions

Several reviews mention an unusual smell. For some, it resembled an old building or attic. Others described a stronger damp or humid odor in the corridors and rooms. One reviewer noticed the hallway smell right away. Another said the humidity was severe enough to affect the stay. In a separate account, cleaner and odor-neutralizer scents reportedly caused headaches and nausea for a member of the travelling party.

That does not mean every room has the same problem. The repetition is still worth noting. Travellers with allergies, sensitivity to humidity or little tolerance for musty smells should treat these reports seriously. One review also mentioned that air conditioning was absent, although the available material does not clarify the setup throughout the property.

Service and breakfast

Housekeeping is another area where expectations may need checking. One guest stayed four nights and said the room was not serviced during that time. Fresh towels and extra toilet paper arrived only after being requested. Another review described a room booked for four people that contained only two of an unspecified item. Room preparation may not always reflect the number of guests.

The breakfast described in the reviews is basic: hard-boiled eggs, waffles, bananas, apples, coffee and orange juice. It should work for travellers who want something to get the day started, though not for anyone expecting a substantial hotel breakfast. Staff responsiveness receives at least some positive mention. Even so, guests may want to clarify service expectations at check-in.

Who should choose it

The Mayflower Hotel is a reasonable fit for travellers who value historic surroundings, central city access and a budget-conscious stay. They will need to be comfortable with an older building and the possibility of uneven room conditions. Visitors who need dependable climate control, fragrance-free rooms or daily housekeeping without having to ask may be better served elsewhere.

Guests should confirm the housekeeping schedule before settling in. They should also request enough towels and supplies for the full stay, then report any odor concern immediately. Bars and restaurants nearby are a practical plus. The front room, with its period details, offers one of the clearest views of the hotel’s character.

The experience appears highly room dependent. For some travellers, that will be a fair exchange for the atmosphere. For others, the compromises may outweigh it.

Plan the rest of the trip

• More hotels in United States
• What else is worth booking in San Francisco, United States
• All United States travel reviews
• Browse every destination we cover