Margaritaville Island Reserve Riviera Maya: Review Summary

Overall impression

Margaritaville Island Reserve Riviera Maya receives a Google rating of 4.5 from 2307 reviews. The public feedback presents it as a polished, upbeat resort in Puerto Morelos, with service emerging as the strongest theme. Guests repeatedly describe the property as clean, tidy, well maintained and modern. Several reviewers also single out staff members by name for remembering preferences, keeping drinks topped up and making meals feel personal.

The atmosphere is clearly part of the appeal. Reviews mention entertainment at LandShark, active pool service and a generally fun setting. Couples appear in the feedback, though the resort also suits travellers who want plenty happening around the pool and restaurants rather than a quiet, self-contained stay.

Rooms, service and atmosphere

Room feedback is notably positive. One reviewer called the room the best they had stayed in, while another described the rooms as great. Cleanliness comes up often, both in comments about accommodation and in wider observations about the resort grounds.

Staff service is the most consistent strength in the sample. Erick, Noel and Max are praised for their friendly breakfast and lunch service. Eliseo receives a warm mention for poolside attention, while Alain, Moises, Domingo, Anthony and Fidel are also named in positive comments about bars, restaurants and service. That level of specific praise suggests guests notice the staff’s effort, not just the setting.

Food and drinks

Dining reviews are mixed. Some guests report plenty of choice and meals that exceeded expectations. The Italian restaurant and the outside restaurant receive particularly enthusiastic feedback, with steak and egg tacos singled out as a favourite. LandShark also features positively in comments about entertainment and drinks service.

The Boat House buffet is the clearest point of criticism. One reviewer found the food subpar, while another described the steak house as disappointing. Drinks are also described as inconsistent in one review. The sample therefore points to a resort where restaurant experiences may vary considerably by venue and by visit.

What to know before booking

The resort suits travellers who value attentive service, a clean contemporary setting and a busy all-inclusive-style resort routine. It is less compelling for guests who want uniform food quality across every restaurant or who are particularly sensitive to changes in drink preparation.

One review reports that two guests became fairly sick during the stay. That is a serious individual account, but the available sample does not establish a broader pattern. Another review raises concerns about a dress-code decision at the Boat House buffet, describing enforcement as inconsistent. Guests may want to check restaurant attire rules before arriving.

Overall, the public feedback is favourable, with service, rooms and upkeep doing most of the work. Dining needs more caution. The resort’s 4.5 Google rating reflects a strong overall reception, but the critical reviews point to specific areas worth checking rather than ignoring.

Plan the rest of the trip

• More resorts in Mexico
• What else is worth booking in Puerto Morelos, Mexico
• All Mexico travel reviews
• Browse every destination we cover