Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina Review

The setting

Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina is beside the marina on Shelter Island, looking across the bay toward downtown San Diego. In public ratings and reviews, the setting comes up again and again as the hotel’s main advantage. Guests talk about the boats, the water and the relative quiet, while still being close to the city. Around the pool, hot tub, restaurant and bar, the property feels closer to a resort than a typical roadside hotel.

The outlook does much of the work. Several reviewers specifically mention marina views, and one especially appreciated seeing the downtown skyline across the bay. The exterior also made a good first impression on a visitor who toured the property before deciding whether to stay.

Rooms and facilities

Most room comments are positive, but the experience is not entirely consistent. Reviewers describe the rooms as spacious, clean, comfortable and well furnished. A marina view and practical layout were also praised. One couple celebrating an anniversary called the room perfect for the occasion, with staff helping confirm that the booking suited what they wanted.

The pool and hot tub get frequent attention in reviews. One guest said the pool was open from 8 a.m. to 11 p.m. and enjoyed having it mostly to themselves in the morning. The attached restaurant and bar are useful too, especially after a day out, when guests would rather stay on the property.

There are some gaps. One review noted that the room had no coffee maker and that basic items were not always easy to access. Another visitor reported a musty smell and found the interior dated and worn after viewing a room. That report sits against the more common descriptions of clean rooms and bathrooms. In practical terms, guests should allow for some variation between rooms or recent updates.

Service and overall feel

Service is among the hotel’s more dependable strengths. Public reviews mention quick check-in and helpful exchanges with desk, housekeeping and restaurant staff. For one anniversary stay, staff added a personal touch by offering congratulations at arrival. Small gestures count, particularly for guests celebrating something.

The hotel has a Google rating of 4.4 from 3,355 reviews, pointing to a broadly strong public reception. The pattern in those ratings and reviews is fairly straightforward: guests who care most about the waterfront location, views and on-site leisure facilities tend to be pleased. Criticism is concentrated on room condition and the absence of certain in-room conveniences.

Who should stay here

Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina is a good fit for couples, repeat San Diego visitors and travellers who prefer a marina setting to a central downtown address. It also suits a short break built around the pool, hot tub and on-site restaurant. Guests concerned about dated interiors or in-room coffee facilities should confirm the room details before arrival and request their preferred view.

Two to three nights is enough to enjoy the property without making it the sole focus of a San Diego trip. The setting is the clearest reason to book. Room consistency is the main caution.

Plan the rest of the trip

• More hotels in United States
• What else is worth booking in San Diego, United States
• All United States travel reviews
• Browse every destination we cover